Share Poll

Poll link

500 px
350 px
250 px
Preview

widget preview:

Width - px Height - px

Close preview
! You are using a non-supported browser Your browser version is not optimised for Toluna, we recommend that you install the latest version Upgrade
With effect from 25 May 2018, we have updated our Privacy Notice. You can read our updated version here.

Arfern

  23 months ago

Language as a barrier to gender equality and inclusivity
Closed

J.K. Rowling has been receiving backlash from the online community in the past week. This is due to her response to the title of an article for Devex, i.e. "Creating a more equal post-COVID-19 world for people who menstruate". The Harry Potter author tweeted: “‘People who menstruate.’ I’m sure there used to be a word for those people. Someone help me out. Wumben? Wimpund? Woomud?” This seemingly simple line from the world-famous writer sparked a controversy overnight, accusing her of transphobia and being a "terf."

So why are people furious? Woman in the strictest sense of the word means an adult that belongs to the female sex. But, since language is fluid and changes continuously, "woman" doesn't only bear this one meaning. Especially now in the woke era, a woman could be anyone who wants to be identified as such. One group that Rowling angered is the trans community who, despite not capable of menstruating, identify themselves as female or woman. Also, transgender men menstruate but don't want to be labeled as women at all. It gets complicated when someone pointed out that women who are menopausal are still women. Some representatives of these groups, and many others, accused the famous author of being a terf.

TERF is an acronym that stands for trans exclusionary radical feminist. A terf is a feminist whose beliefs don't qualify transsexuals as female.

Do you think J.K. Rowling is in the wrong? Or do you think that the LGBTQ+ has overreacted?

My opinion:

To be honest, the title of the article is poorly worded and unnecessarily painted J.K. Rowling to bad light. From the point of view of a writer, I think simply saying "woman" is sufficient, clear, and neutral. Also, I think that verbally abusing and threatening the author defeats the purpose of the advocacy of gender equality and feminism. I am one of the people who believe that the road to equality is through kind words, compassion, and intelligent discussions.
Reply

SharMane0031

  23 months ago
I agree. I mean why would they use the term "someone who menstruates" to describe a female? It's like they were trying to spot a difference between a transwoman and a natural born woman? Woman. The term itself would be the appropriate word to use. Then, it would be left upon the readers to relate themselves as one.
I think the only wrong notion JK Rowling gave in her statement is perceived (for me) in the shift of her tense in her sentence, "There USED to be.." Like she was not welcoming any new definition of a modern woman.
And yes, I am also for gender equality.
0 comments

MarioLuigi3286687

  23 months ago
It's hard to judge people of their different status in life. I don't know what benefits would these people gain if their unreasonable intentions were just merely to verbally abuse others. I guess it's their common nature to hurt the feelings of others just for the sake that they loved doing it so much.
0 comments

bheivness

  23 months ago
I think it's only misinterpret..now adays social media is powerful we should aware of giving or believing in articles
0 comments

rommel09

  23 months ago
Well, we should respect her opinion. I dont understand the need to threaten someone just to prove their point. Personally, I also don't consider transgenders as real women.
0 comments

Copied to clipboard

You’re almost there

In order to create content on the community

Verify your Email / resend
No thanks, I’m just looking

OK
Cancel
We have disabled our Facebook login process. Please enter your Facebook email to receive a password creation link.
Please enter a valid Email
Cancel
We're working on it...
When you upload a picture, our site looks better.
Upload